Push It: Straight to Gay First Time MM (Straight to Gay MM First Time Romance Stories)

When my buddy Dalton and I got bored one summer afternoon, we went sneaking through the bedrooms in his house. When we came upon a dirty toy in one of the bedroom closets, Dalton was shocked. He didn’t want to know those sorts of things about the people closest to him. I couldn’t blame him. The toy wasn’t just your typical eight-inch, pink and vibrating variety. This thing was a monster, made for two people to use at the same time, with two heads and everything!

But I couldn’t help myself but to prank him. So, I took the foot-long toy back to his bedroom and shoved it under his mattress. Of course, Dalton caught on very quick. And when he confronted me, it turned into a game of wits and one-upmanship. When Dalton accused me of being “small” in my shorts, I knew I couldn’t let it stand, so we decided to have a little contest. The loser was going to have to use the toy on themselves while the other watched, and reveled in the humiliation.

But the stakes kept changing and soon enough, Dalton and I had gone farther than we ever expected. Next thing we knew, we were doing the wildest things with each other. I’m straight, and I know Dalton is, too. But for that afternoon, we were putting our straightness on pause, because we were getting down and dirty with not just the big, dirty toy we’d found, but with each other, too…

Read more